Welcome to Michaelangelo's Pizza & Subs
Michaelangelo's Pizza & Subs, located in Greenville, NC, is a beloved destination for those craving authentic New York-style pizza. With an inviting atmosphere and friendly service, it promises a delightful dining experience. Patrons rave about the generous portions and delicious flavors, particularly the signature "all the way" pizza and garlic knots accompanied by a rich homemade dipping sauce. While some customers have noted occasional inconsistencies, many still consider it a go-to spot for satisfying pizza cravings. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or feeding a crowd, Michaelangelo's offers comfort food that feels like home.
Michaelangelo's Pizza & Subs: Reviews & Ratings
I moved from NJ a few years ago and have missed eating good pizza ever since. Holy cow I am so so so happy I found this place! It is amazing NY style pizza!! I highly recommend and understand that they are busy all the time. If you like northern style it is well worth the wait.
I had a 5 star rating a couple of years ago because the food, service and value was all that. I have been back a couple of times this year and so dissapointed. I ordered single slices of pizza and they were so hard to the point that I could barely eat them. I was going to get some garlic knots, but they no longer come with the same amount of homemade sauce to dip. A much larger container before compared to what you receive now is really only enough for about 3 of the knots. When I purchased earlier in the year there was barely any garlic and very tuff. I felt I had to update this since my view has changed. I will try again in the future in hopes that I can update this review in a more positive light. This was my experience up until about several months ago. Best "all the way" Pizza...but try the 12 piece garlic knots which come with homemade tomato dipping sauce for the win!
What a delicious slice of Hawaiian pizza. Huge, thin, NY style. Wicked yummy! Ice tea is excellent! Guys at the counter were friendly and kind. Looking forward to my next visit.
Visiting from Delaware and we needed pizzas for Sunday football. We decided to go there because I've seen the pictures in Google so we tried it out. The pizzas were actually really good. New York style and it was pretty big.
This is exactly how I like my pizza. Not pretentious like some other options in Greenville, but not a Domino's. Good NY style pies, reasonable fare, friendly service.
I love getting food from here because the associates are always very friendly. I am not very familiar with different foods but I ask questions about the food and they were able to let me try the garlic knots and now it is my favorite. They are friendly, fast and clean, and I love that about them. I highly recommend and I’ll continue to buy my food from here.
Food is always hot and fresh. The nicest guys work in there! Great place to eat. My granddaughter loves the spaghetti and meatballs.
Large pizza slices so yummy Great service Awesome canollis
Location
-
1912 E Fire Tower Rd #105, Greenville, NC 27858, United States Hotline: +1 252-758-1116
Welcome to Michaelangelo's Pizza & Subs, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Greenville, North Carolina. Located at 1912 E Fire Tower Rd #105, this pizzeria has quickly earned a reputation for serving authentic New York-style pizza that transports you straight to the bustling streets of NYC. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Michaelangelo's is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts.
Customers rave about the generous portions of their pizzas, with one reviewer, Sarah B, expressing her delight at finding a slice reminiscent of her New Jersey roots. The expression "Holy cow" captures the excitement of sinking your teeth into a hot, fresh pie, perfectly baked and topped just right. From classic cheese to creative toppings, each pizza is crafted with care and authenticity, ensuring a satisfying bite every time.
Yet, like any establishment, Michaelangelo's has its ups and downs, as reflected in reviews. While many celebrate the delicious offerings, some customers expressed disappointment with specific orders, such as the garlic knots and pizza slices that did not meet their expectations. Vickie Olguin’s review notes a shift in portion sizes and quality over time, reminding us that consistency can be a challenge in the restaurant industry. Nonetheless, her nostalgia for the "all the way" pizza and those beloved garlic knots suggests a hopeful spirit for future visits.
On the positive side, dedicated staff and a friendly atmosphere contribute to the overall experience at Michaelangelo's. Jennifer Seibert highlights the warmth of the service and the tremendous flavor of her Hawaiian pizza, emphasizing the joy of a well-crafted meal. Amber O echoes this sentiment, praising the down-to-earth vibe and the value offered at this pizzeria. For those who appreciate a casual dining atmosphere, this place strikes the right balance.
Whether you're picking up a quick slice or catering for game day, Michaelangelo's Pizza & Subs is ready to satisfy your cravings. So, next time you're in Greenville, be sure to stop by and indulge in a slice of their renowned pizza. You might just find yourself returning for more.